Preview

Vestnik natsional'nogo issledovatel'skogo yadernogo universiteta "MIFI"

Advanced search

THE COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF DECISION TREES AND NEURAL NETWORKS METHODS IN THE CREDIT INSTITUTIONS CLASSIFICATION PROBLEM

https://doi.org/10.26583/vestnik.2022.12

Abstract

In recent years, decision trees and neural network have been widely used in computer vision problems such as object recognition, text classification, gesture recognition, spam detection, semantic segmentation and data clustering. The article discusses the decision tree and neural networks methods application in the problem of classifying credit institutions as economic security objects. The analysis results of data on credit institutions activities of using different methods of decision trees: C5, CHAID, C&R and QUEST, as well as neural networks are presented. The highest overall classification accuracy of the analyzed objects was achieved using the C5 decision tree algorithm and amounted to 81 %. The overall classification accuracy using the CHAID algorithm was 68 %, the C&R algorithm was 71 %, and the QUEST algorithm was 66 %. Based on the C5 algorithm results, a set of rules was generated to determine whether a bank belongs to a certain class. According to the methods of decision trees and neural networks, the most informative performance indicators of credit institutions were selected in terms of their division into two classes: trustworthy and high-risk.

About the Authors

E. P. Akishina
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research
Russian Federation


V. V. Ivanov
Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, National Research Nuclear University ««MEPhI»
Russian Federation


A. V. Kryanev
National Research Nuclear University ««MEPhI»
Russian Federation


A. S. Prikazchikova
National Research Nuclear University ««MEPhI»
Russian Federation


References

1. Paklin N.B., Oreshkov V.I. Chapter 9 // Business Analytics: From Data to Knowledge (+ CD): Tutorial. 2nd ed. – St. Petersburg: Piter, 2013. – pp. 428 - 472. – ISBN 978-5-459-00717-6.

2. Levitin A. V. Chapter 10. Power Limits of Algorithms: Decision Trees // Algorithms. Introduction to development and analysis - M.: Williams, 2006. – pp. 409 - 417. – 576 p. – ISBN 978-5-8459-0987-9.

3. Prikazchikova A.S. The neural networks and the principal components method using for the identification of credit institutions potentially involved in the money laundering process / Ivanov V.V., Akishina E.P., Prikazchikova A.S. // Proceedings of the Issyk-Kul Forum of Accountants and Auditors of Central Asian Countries. 2022 No. 2 (37) P. 294-296.

4. Statistica http://statsoft.ru.

5. Haykin, Simon Neural networks and learning machines / Simon Haykin.– 3rd ed. p. cm. Rev. ed of: Neural networks. 2nd ed., 1999.

6. Gladilin P.E., Bochenina K.O., Machine learning technologies - St. Petersburg: ITMO University, 2020. – 75 p.

7. IBM SPSS Modeler https://www.ibm.com/products/spss-modeler.


Supplementary files

Review

For citations:


Akishina E.P., Ivanov V.V., Kryanev A.V., Prikazchikova A.S. THE COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF DECISION TREES AND NEURAL NETWORKS METHODS IN THE CREDIT INSTITUTIONS CLASSIFICATION PROBLEM. Vestnik natsional'nogo issledovatel'skogo yadernogo universiteta "MIFI". 2022;11(6):442-449. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.26583/vestnik.2022.12

Views: 316


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2304-487X (Print)