Structure of the Support System for Making Optimal Decisions during the Decommissioning of Nuclear Facilities

   The structure of the optimal decision support system for the decommissioning of nuclear facilities is examined. The proposed structure provides the analysis of various options for decommissioning the facility under consideration for atomic energy use and the selection of the best option for decommissioning it. The system takes into account uncertainties in the source data, including uncertainties that are described using fuzzy values. The decommissioning options are evaluated by several particular indicators, reducing them to two or three aggregated indicators.

1. Abramov A. A., Dorofeev A. N., Komarov E. A., Linge In. I., Abalkina I. L., Vedernikova M. V., Birukov D. V., Iordanov A. S., Linge I. I., Kovalchuk D. V., Kruchkov D. V., Utkin S. S., Aliksahin R. M., Hamaza A. A., Bochkarev V. V., Supataeva O. A., Kononov V. V., Tikhonovsky V. L., Ivanov O. P., Pavlenko V. I., Semenov S. G., Chesnokov A. V. Zakluchitelnii tom trehtomnoi monografii “Problemi yadernogo naslediya I puti ih resheniya”, posvyashenni zavershaemomu etapu jiznennogo cikla obekta ispolzovaniya atomnoi energii – vivodu iz ekspluatacii. “Problemi yadernogo naslediya I puti ih resheniya. Vivod iz ekspluatacii”. Pod obshei redakciei akademika RAN L. A. Bolshova, N. P. Laverova, chl.-kor. RAN I. I. Lingue. [The final volume of the three-volume monograph “Problems of Nuclear Legacy and the Ways of Their Solution”, dedicated to the final stage of the life cycle of an atomic energy use facility – decommissioning. “The problems of nuclear legacy and ways to solve them. Removal from service”. Under the general editorship of the academician of the RAS L. A. Bolshova, N. P. Laverova, Corr. RAS I. I. Linge]. M.: 2015, 316 pp.

2. Abalkina I. L., Birukov D. V., Vedernikova M. V., Dorogov V. I., Ilushkin A. I., Iordanov A. S., Kovalchuk D. V., Linge I. I., Obodinski A. N., Savkin M. N., Samoilov A. A., Abramov A. A., Dorofeev A. N., Komarov E. A., Linge In. I., Kurindina L. A., Bochkarev V. V., Hamaza A. A., Shadilov A. E., Sharafutdinov R. B., Kovalchuk A. A., Kamanin A. N., Kulikov A. A., Ivanova O. I., Kosova O. E., Lavrov K. N., Starkova M. V., Barchukov V. G., Kochetkova O. A. Inventarizatsiya yaderno i radiatsionno opasnih obektov. Ojidaemie rezultati I perspektivi ih ispolzovaniya. [Inventory of nuclear and radiation hazardous facilities. Expected Results and Prospects for Their Use]. Moscow, preprint IBRAE RAS, No. IBRAE-2014-05, 2014, 39 pp.

3. Abramov A. A., Dorofeev A. N., Komarov E. A., Kudryavtsev E. G., Bolshov L. A., Linge I. I., Abalkina I. L., Birukov D. V., Vedernikova M. V., Hamaza A. A., Sharafutdinov R. B., Bochkarev V. V. K voprosu otsenki obema yadernogo naslediya v atomnoi promishlennosti i na inih obektah mirnogo ispolzovaniya atomnoi energii v Rossii. [On the issue of assessing the volume of nuclear legacy in the nuclear industry and other facilities for the peaceful use of atomic energy in Russia]. Nuclear and radiation safety, No. 3 (73), 2014, pp. 1–11.

4. Tezici doklada “Nauchno-metodicheskoe soprovojdenie meropriyatii federalnoi yselevoi programmi “Obecpechenie yadernoi i radiatsionnoi bezopasnosti na 2016–2020 godi i na period do 2030 goda” po podgotovke k vivodu i vivodu iz ekspluatatsii obekyov yadernogo naslediya i po obrasheniu s osobimi radioaktivnimi othodami” v obespechenie meropriyatiya “Razrabotka i prakticheskoe ispolzovanie pri vivode iz ekspluatatsii yaderno i radiatsionno opasnih obektov novih visoko tehnologichnih tehnologii”. [Abstracts of the report “Scientific and methodological support for the activities of the federal target program “Ensuring Nuclear and Radiation Safety for 2016–2020 and for the period until 2030 ”on preparation for the decommissioning and decommissioning of nuclear heritage objects and on the management of special radioactive waste” events “Development and practical use of new highly effective technologies in the decommissioning of nuclear and radiation hazardous facilities”]. NTS FBU “STC NRS” dated 11/17/2016.

5. Federalnaya tselevaya programma “ Obecpechenie yadernoi i radiatsionnoi bezopasnosti na 2016–2020 godi i na period do 2030 goda” [Federal Target Program “Ensuring Nuclear and Radiation Safety for 2016–2020 and for the Period until 2030”].

6. International Structure for Decommissioning Costing (ISDC) of Nuclear Installations, IAEA, 2012, 195 p.

7. Costs of Decommissioning Nuclear Power Plants. IAEA, 2016, 260 pp.

8. Financing the Decommissioning of Nuclear Facilities. IAEA, 2016, 23 pp.

9. Emets P. E., Kovalevich O. M., Kryanev A. V., Sharafutdinov R. B. Matematicheskie modeli rascheta investicionnoi effektivnosti vivoda iz ekspluatatsii YaROO. [Mathematical models for calculating the investment efficiency of decommissioning a nuclear power plant]. Preprint MEPhI 002-2007. M .: MEPhI, 2007, 27 pp.

10. Emets P. E., Kovalevich O. M., Kryanev A. V., Neretin V. A., Sharafutdinov R. B. Sistemni podhod pri finansirovanii meropriyatii po vivodu iz ekspluatatsii YaROO, klassifitsiruemih v zavisimosti ot kategorii ih YaROO. [A systematic approach to financing the decommissioning of nuclear weapons, classified according to the category of their nuclear weapons]. Preprint MEPhI 005-2007. M.: MEPhI, 2007, 23 pp.

11. Emets P. E., Kryanev A. V. Metodika otsenki ekonomichskoi effektivnosti vivoda iz ekspluatatsii yaderno i radiatsionno opasnih obektov. [Methodology for assessing the economic efficiency of decommissioning of nuclear and radiation hazardous facilities], Atomic Energy Bulletin, 2008, No. 11, pp. 4–7.

12. Emets P. E., Kryanev A. V. Investitsionnaya effektivnost vivoda iz ekspluatatsii yaderno i radiatsionno opasnih obektov (YaROO). [Investment efficiency of decommissioning of nuclear and radiation hazardous facilities (NROO)]. Nuclear and radiation safety. 2011, No. 1 (59), pp. 10–19.

13. Bochkarev V. V., Kryanev A. V., Hanbikova D. T. Ranjirovanie yaderno i radiatsionno opasnih obektov, ekspluatatsiya kotorih prekrashena. “Informatsionno–tielekommunikatsionnie tehnologii i matematicheskoe modelirovanie vicokotehnologicheskih system”: materiali Vserossiskoi konferentsii s mejdunarodnim uchastiem. [Ranking of nuclear and radiation hazardous facilities whose operation has been discontinued. “Information and telecommunication technologies and mathematical modeling of high-tech systems”: materials of the All-Russian Conference with international participation]. Moscow, PFUR, 2014, pp. 195–197 (In Russian).

14. Addressing Uncertainties in Cost Estimates for Decommissioning Nuclear Facilities. IAEA, 2017, 68 p.

15. Kryanev A. V., Lukin G. V. Matematicheskie metodi obrabotki neopredelennih dannih. [Mathematical methods for processing uncertain data], M.: Fizmatlit, 2006.

16. Orlovskii S. A. Problemi prinyatiya reshenii pri nechetkoi ishodnoi informatsii [Decision problems with fuzzy source information]. M.: Nauka, 1981.

17. Pegat A. Nechetkoe modelirovanie i upravlenie. [Fuzzy modeling and control]. M.: BINOM. Knowledge Laboratory, 2009.

18. Semenov S. S., Voronov E. M., Poltavskii A. V., Kryanev A. V. Metodi prinyatiya reshenii v zadachah otsenki kachestva i tehnicheskogo urovnya slojnih tehnicheskih system. [Decision-making methods for assessing the quality and technical level of complex technical systems]. М.: URSS, 2015.

19. RB-153-18 “Rekomendatsii po obosnovaniu vibora variant vivoda iz ekspluatatsii obektov ispolzovaniya atomnoi energii”. Utverjdteno prikazom Federalnoi slujbi po ecologicheskomu i atomnomu nadzoru ot 29 dekabrya 2018 g. [“Recommendations on the justification of the choice of option for decommissioning of nuclear facilities”. Approved by order of the Federal Service for Ecological, Technological and Nuclear Supervision of December 29, 2018”]. Moscow, № 666, 22 pp.